top of page

A Jewish Island in the Arab Sea

Israel ben Dor / A Jewish Island in the Arab Sea – Image and reality in the development of the relations between Israel with the Arab expanse in its first years (1947 – 1956)

 

The study deals with the image of the Arabs of the Jewish settlement and the State of Israel in the formative years of the Israeli – Arab conflict and their affiliation to the historical reality. The conflict with the Arabs, that were defined as the enemy, was perceived as existential conflict and affected all walks of life. Therefore, the approach taken in this study was to examine the reflection of the images in a broad spectrum of social and cultural phenomena, relying on a wide range of sources.

 

The negative dimension, which ascribed negative attributes to the Arabs and painted the conflict in dark colors, constitutes the majority of the system of images and the perception of the Arabs as the enemy and the perception of the expected threat from which it constantly worsened. The Arabs, their culture, Arab society and the expanse were referred to, inter alia, as failed, ignorant, murderous, and revengeful. The Arab nationality was identified with Fascism and Nazism. The Arabs in the Land of Israel were perceived as a most dangerous enemy and also after their defeat and the establishment of the State of Israel, they were perceived as a “Fifth Column”. The Jewish side attributed humanism, initiative, love of building and creativity to itself, and therefore the State of Israel viewed itself as a “Jewish Island in the Arab Sea”.

Through the "lens" which the Jewish side viewed the reality, were components that resulted from the Jewish History, from the Holocaust and from the European culture (including pre-conceived ideas and stereotypes) and, in this way, distortions were created which frequently lead to wrong decisions. Thus, for example, prior to the War of Independence, the Jewish settlement tended to denigrate the Arab armies and the chance that they will invade Israel. The surprise and the shock created after the invasion lead, during the 1950s, to the extreme assessment that Israel is under immediate danger of an overall Arab attack. Another outstanding example of an image in which a serious deformation occurred with respect to the reality was the image of the Arab minority as a “Fifth Column” and as a danger to the security of the State, which lead to the loss of an historic opportunity to build up a different relationship between Jews and Arabs.

bottom of page